Using iMag in Corporate Worship

A couple weeks ago I was fortunate enough to attend Catalyst West, a conference designed to encourage, inspire, and challenge the leaders of tomorrow, those in our church who will live in and live out the Kingdom of God.

It was a brilliantly assembled (and beautifully diverse… in some ways) gathering of men (and women… although not enough, if you ask me) that I really think accomplished what it set out to.

I may post further observations and thoughts in later posts, but for right now I want to talk about what is commonly referred to as “iMag”, or Image Magnification.

iMag is essentially the process of using cameras to project on to large screens what is happening on the main stage. Such as the below pic of Chris Tomlin leading worship.

Chris Tomlin leading at CatWest

You can see, above and behind Chris, a large screen projecting shots of the band.

Many churches use this technique, iMag, during their services, and if I may I’d like to give my thoughts on it. What’s that? You didn’t really ask me for my thoughts? Oh that’s okay… I tend to give unsolicited opinions often…

5 Reasons I Like iMag

1) It Connects You to What is Happening on the Stage. If you are in a large auditorium, and you get stuck in the way back (or way top), then you can feel disconnected from what’s going on. You also miss facial expressions and other non-verbals. Making a 10-foot face is a simple solution. Imagine sitting in the below auditorium, in the nosebleeds. Without iMag, you just might get frustrated enough to show up earlier next week for a better seat.

Rob Bell speaking at Catalyst '09

2) It Looks Cool: C’mon, admit it. When you’ve got cameras sweeping across the room on giant booms, and camera guys running around the stage, you think: wow, this is something really special! Haven’t you always wondered how that lead guitar part goes? Bam! Solo shot on the stud guitarist, extreme close up of his hands flying across the fretboard. Feel sad that the drummer is always in the back, blocked by cymbals and stands? Bam! Solo shot on the drummer’s face as he sweats and bobs to the music. Wonder how you too can have awesome emo/metro hair like the worship leader? Bam! Solo shot on the leader!

3) It Provides Service Opportunities for Techies in Your Congregation. I run in to a lot of people who are frustrated because they love to zoom in on stuff, but their church doesn’t have a place for them. Now, just keep adding camera shots, and more and more people can serve!

4) It Gives You Something to Watch if You Don’t Like Singing: Not everyone likes to sing, or always feels like singing, but with iMag you at least provide them with something to watch if they want. If you just have graphic backgrounds behind your lyrics, that gets boring fast. And if you can’t ‘see the preacher, you’ll easily tune out. But if you can watch the constant panning and zooming, the cutting and fading of the worship band, that’s like being at home watching t.v.! I can just tap my feet to the music and watch the show without feeling like I have to sing along!

5) It Forces Hygiene: Gone are the days when the bassist can just roll out of bed, slumber on to the stage, and do his thing. Now, he’s got to be ready should he get a close up. Ladies can’t skip the make-up in the morning, cause their face could be the balance on whether people engage in worship that morning, or grimace and disengage. Speakers must be well shaved and clothes well pressed. You can’t hide anything in 20 feet of high definition.

5 Reasons I Do Not Like iMag

1) It Can Be A Distraction: This really applies to the music section of a service. If my only opportunity to follow along with the lyrics is to look at a large screen showing me everything the band is doing, for me that is a negative. ┬áIf I know the song, I’ll close my eyes and sing along. If I don’t, I’m forced to read them from a screen, which is fine and good. But I don’t want to have to watch a music-video while I’m doing it.

2) It Can Confuse the Focus: Worship, I think we can all agree, is about the King and for the King. Obviously churches and people who utilize iMag for worship know and believe this as well, I’m not saying they don’t. But doesn’t it send mixed messages? To quote Shane Hipps: the media IS the message. If we show lead guitar guy shredding the lick, or zoom in on singer-lady’s face as she belts that high-C, aren’t we, in a sense, saying that these people and what they are doing is the focus? Not intentionally, maybe, but unintentionally absolutely. “Just ignore me… pretend it’s just you and God right now… let me and my voice just fade to the background,” says the worship leader WITH THE GIANT HEAD. It’s hard enough to empower our congregations to focus on Jesus as they worship, but aren’t we compounding the issue by asking them to ignore the show we’re broadcasting on the screen? It’s like telling our kids they have to eat dinner before they get dessert, WHILE WE OURSELVES are chomping on a chocolate chip cookie with our broccoli untouched.

3) It Puts Weird Pressure on the People on Stage: Some of the camera guys I was watching at Catalyst were getting so close to the guitar players, I felt nervous FOR them. How in the world do we expect the musicians to be worshiping themselves when they are constantly thinking “uh-oh, am I on the screen for this one? I better not screw up… and I better make sure my face looks really worshipful…” Certainly people can get used to this, to where they don’t really think about it anymore, but is that really a good thing in the end? It’s already enough of an issue to fight against the complex of feeling like a rock-star while on stage, performing for thousands of people, but you put my face on a giant screen, and now I feel even more important!

Aaron Keyes leading worship at CatWest

4) It Feeds the Entertain-me Machine: One of the major criticisms of the modern, western, evangelical church is that it has become too consumeristic. Rather than asking church-goers “how can YOU serve people,” we ask “how can WE serve you?” We create a environment where people come to be entertained. We put on a show for them, hoping they’ll come back next week with a friend. We don’t require anything from them, just that they sit back and enjoy the show. I feel like using iMag in worship does nothing to combat this notion, and more likely does much to convey it.

5) It Doesn’t Feel Right: Okay, so this is pretty vague, and sort of a lame 5th reason. But there’s just something about iMag that I can’t quite put my finger on (other than the previous 4 reasons, of course) that just makes me cringe a bit. While the motives of those using iMag are undoubtedly noble, the final product looks, well, like that: a product. I don’t feel invited in to engage in worship, I feel invited to join a concert, to watch a performance, to see how good looking and talented other people are. I end up feeling bad for the people on stage, wishing they didn’t have to have themselves projected on large screens. I find myself desperate to look elsewhere, even if it means I cannot sing-a-long because I don’t know the words. And in the end, I realize that all I’m really thinking about is the use of iMag itself, and not Jesus and His worship.

Conclusion: I don’t totally hate iMag. My first “reason to like” iMag remains true, however I would apply that only to the Preacher/Speaker. I just think the game changes too much when it comes to the music and worship. Yes, use iMag to blow up the head of the preacher so we can follow along and be engaged. But leave it off when the band plays. So what if I can’t see the singers face, I’m not here to watch him. I don’t want to condemn or judge those of my friends and comrades who utilize iMag (or are at a church that forces them to use iMag), for I know that much of this is preference and personal conviction. But I do think there is enough inherent to the medium itself that should cause us to question “why” we use it, and what messages are we conveying when we do.

What about you?

Does your church use iMag? If so, what are your thoughts? If not, how would you feel if they started this week?

Or have you been to events where they used iMag? How did you feel about it?

As always, I welcome your comments…

6 thoughts on “Using iMag in Corporate Worship

  1. Not surprisingly, but I wholeheartedly agree with you for all of your stated reasons, primarily the 5th. It just feels odd to me, in a very bad way.

    That said, I thought I came to read this post because I thought I’d get the opportunity to bash iMag, some new fangled iPhone app for use in worship! ;~)

    • Hah! You would think that… And there probably IS some new fangled app for this purpose. Maybe, it’s call iMag-mini: an app for the iPhone that let’s you stream directly to your phone whatever is being broadcasted on the big screens! I think I’m on to something here…

  2. Colbz,

    I haven’t been on here in a while, but I scanned through the reasons and the “for” reasons are funny to me…esp. the last one…I hope they were meant to entertain b/c they did me! ;) The “against” reasons are right on…man…all of the above for me.

    THE medium IS the message is the crucial bit…the already “rocked out” worship style becomes even more “rocked out” and it furthers the idea that worship is experience, and how “good” or “bad” depends on ones experience…aka…they’re feelings. THe more I’m commited to liturgy, the more I realize what worship is. It’s an act more than an experience….the latter is so overblown it can in subtle ways twist worship into “how I feel”…

    OH….Your #5 is the Spirit of God Colby…don’t let this kind of thing into your church unless you want to go more into the “entertain me” model…

    • Platonic,

      I started out the “for” list thinking I might be able to come up with more than just one (because honestly, the first one is a legit and arguably ‘good’ reason… at least regarding the preacher/speaker), but once I got to #2, I realized it was hopeless. So my cynical and sarcastic self took over…

      I’ve really been operating, for about the past 2 years now, on worship as “telling the story of God, over and over again, in many different ways.” And in so doing, when we “tell” God’s story through worship, we are provided opportunity and space to realign our OWN stories WITH God’s story. This, I feel, helps in some ways to remove the demands of seeking a certain “feeling” or “experience” in worship. If the focus is no longer about me, and how I liked/didn’t like the worship, or what I got out of it, and instead is shifted to simply telling God’s story (and come what may), then I think we succeed in getting closer to biblical worship.

      And thanks for your insights in to my #5… I should’ve pegged that earlier (that it was more than just a ‘gut’ feeling, but a conviction of God’s Spirit ‘in’ me), but that’s beauty of friendship and fellowship and relationship… YOU get to help ME (which I wish we lived closer so we could still be doing in person!)

  3. We agree again! While I may like it at a concert or a Beth Moore because I can see in a large stadium, I would not like it on Sundays at church. I am not there for a performance. I am there to worship my King and it is hard enough to stay focused on that with a band in front of me on stage, let alone 10 feet tall!!

  4. Colbz,

    Thanks for the comments they are as usual insightful and interesting. I’ll have to reflect more about things, and would love to see what you’re doing, and then reflect….but oh well. Maybe someday!

    About the telling of the story, I suppose the question begged is “what is the story” and is it “being told” in the “right way”….correct? Where have you found, as a leader of worship, a storyteller of sorts I suppose, that you are being successful, in the terms you said, and in the other light, where have you found unsucess, in terms of the “demand” for a certain “experience”?

    I wish we could go to a coffee shop and chat….until then….the internet will have to suffice.

    Yours,
    NIck

Enter the conversation here...

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s